Sarah Carter Finds Her Rhythm Beyond the NCAA System
February 19, 2026
By
Anna F.
Cut from the University of Washington after injuries and a coaching change, Sarah Carter rewrote her path through a transfer, a pivotal Grand Canyon trail race, and a rebuild at Colorado State culminating in a pro trail breakthrough at UTMB events.
Sarah Carter arrived at the University of Washington as one of Arizona’s brightest young distance talents. A Division I state champion in cross country, she left Phoenix for Seattle with a clear trajectory: compete, progress, go pro. Instead, injuries and a coaching change derailed her freshman and sophomore seasons. Weeks before the semester ended, she was cut from the team.
Sarah Carter (Credit: Ultrarunning)
Advised by some to step away from competitive running, Carter chose otherwise. She entered the NCAA transfer portal and began searching for a mountain program that aligned with her long-term vision.
On the drive to a summer job, she stopped at the North Rim of the Grand Canyon to run a trail half marathon, a spontaneous decision she now describes as pivotal.
The race, she says, reminded her why she started running.
Carter transferred to Colorado State University, where she rebuilt both confidence and performance.
Over five years, she lowered her 5,000 meter personal best from 17 minutes to 15:44.
Encouraged by her coach to consider professional running, she pivoted toward trail racing after graduation.
Her breakthrough came at Chiang Mai Thailand by UTMB in 2024, her first 50k, where she discovered what she calls a natural rhythm on steep climbs.
In 2025, as a Topo athlete, she placed 15th overall female and third American at UTMB’s OCC.
Sometimes losing a spot on a roster is the moment an athlete finally finds where she truly belongs.